Mixing Munsell neutrals

Neutral stripes & Munsell book
Color swatches from the home improvement store (right) in comparison with the color swatches from the Munsell Student Book.

Having some neutral values at hand is very handy. You can use them for a value scale or to mix with higher chroma colors (of the same value) to make them more neutral. If you have problems judging the value of a high chroma color squint your eyes.

I’ve got the Munsell student book*, and it contains the Munsell neutrals scale. But the problem with the matte chips from the book is, that you can not place paint dabs onto it and whipe it off afterwards. So what you need is some kind of glossy color swatch – and those from the home improvement store should be glossy.

grayscale-stick based on Munsell neutrals
Value stick with holes and matte neutral chips from the Munsell student book

As you can see in the above picture I wasn’t able to match some of the neutrals perfectly due to the matte chips (and little patience). Some are spot on but some are too warm. So I borrowed the neutrals from someone who has the big Munsell book, which contains chips with a glossy surface. Now I was able to check the neutrals better.

Munsell neutrals chips
The 9 glossy chips from the big Munsell book. Perfect white and black can’t be made with paints so there are only 9 chips in the 11 value scale by Munsell.
value still not matching
Still not matching value and neutral hue
value perfect match
Perfect match of value and hue
broken palette knife
Oooops 🙂
in syringe
Syringes are a better alternative for empty paint tubes: easier to fill and much cheaper.
4 values in syringes
4 values in syringes
needed materials
These are the paints that I’ve used: Titanium White, Ivory Black and Burnt Umber.

The results

The above picture shows the paints that I’ve used. But I had a hard time mixing some neutrals, so I needed a little bit of either Cadmium Yellow or Cadmium Red – depending on the direction I needed to go. Note that mixing Titanium White with Ivory Black will result in a cool color and not a neutral as one would expect. Ivory Black actually is a very dark blue (try it yourself by mixing it with yellow – you’ll get a green).

Extra tip

While a commercial Munsell value scale can be quite pricy* you can try to substitute it with free color swatches from the home improvement store. Compare them carefully – some will look somewhat greenish, some reddish ect. Choose the most neutral looking ones. Compare all of them with each other. In this picture you can see the little differences. From left to right: neutral, neutral, too yellow, too green, too purple, too blue.

Comparison between color swatches from the home improvement store. The two on the left side are perfectly neutral.

* Affiliate links

More from my site

  • Yvon’s Méthode de DessinYvon’s Méthode de Dessin Darren Rousar - author of the book 'Cast Drawing - Using the sight Size Approach' which I read before I approached my cast drawing of the female bust has found a little treasure and he […]
  • Review – Scott Waddell’s new instructional video “Drawing & Painting”Review – Scott Waddell’s new instructional video “Drawing & Painting” I've written about Scott Waddell before (see here). On December 17th he has published another video for purchase. The price of 37$ (~27€) is very generous! You'll get over 70 minutes of […]
  • Advices from a professional artistAdvices from a professional artist In 2006 I was happy to find an artist near where I live who has attended a classical atelier in Florence. Born in Jugoslavia, artist Michael Milosevic, who lived in Canada for a long […]

4 thoughts on “Mixing Munsell neutrals”

    • Hello Deborah.

      I bought my syringes at the pharmacy for 0.20€/piece. My experience is that 5 ml tubes serve me well. The ones I used for the neutrals are 20ml and they aren’t filled up completely. The 5ml syringes that I used for my premixed colors last – if filled up to the top – very long. Important is to seal them air tight which is not easy to do. In case it is clogged you can use a nail to push through the dried paint.

      Or you paint faster 😉


Leave a Comment